Thursday, January 13, 2011

Tapestry Table of Contents




Table of Contents

  1. Introduction of Theme: Imperfection

  2. Presentation of Myth: Achilles Heel

  3. Myth Rationale

  4. First Quote: “Better a diamond with a flaw than a pebble without one.”- Confucius

  5. Quote Reflection & Significance to Theme

  6. Poem: The Flaw by Molly Peacock

  7. Poem Reflection

  8. Excerpt from Independent Novel, Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk

  9. Novel Excerpt Reflection

  10. Excerpt from The Perfection of Imperfection by Christopher Alexander

  11. Essay Excerpt Reflection

  12. Excerpt from The Empty Mirror: Experience in a Japanese Zen Monastery by Janwillem van de Wetering

  13. Essay Excerpt Reflection

  14. Excerpt from Human Imperfection by Ergo

  15. Essay Excerpt Reflection

  16. Script Excerpt from film Good Will Hunting

  17. Film Excerpt Reflection

  18. Second Quote: “People throw away what they could have by insisting on perfection, which they cannot have, and looking for it where they will never find it.”- Edith Schaeffer

  19. Second Quote Reflection & Significance to Theme

  20. Quote Excerpt from Bible

  21. Quote Reflection

  22. Poem: Perfection by Ammon Taylor

  23. Poem Reflection

  24. Excerpt from Independent Novel, Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger

  25. Novel Excerpt Reflection

  26. Excerpt from The Catalogue of Correctable Omnipresent Human Flaws by Edward Smith

  27. Essay Excerpt Reflection

  28. Excerpt from Reflections: Human Imperfection by Andrew Peters

  29. Essay Excerpt Reflection

  30. Conclusion & Closing Words on Theme

Introduction to Theme: Imperfection



To different people, imperfection alludes to different things; to some, being imperfect and having flaws are what render us all human. 'Imperfection is beauty', said Marilyn Monroe and these are the words that some people choose to live by. Others still, believe that imperfection is indicative of failure and that they must attempt to bring themselves to a state of total perfection: a state that is always constantly just out of their reach.

These views on imperfection fluctuate depending on various things: for example, someone who grew up in a very religious home may be led to believe that they must model themselves in the image of whatever 'perfect' God they believe in, though this is not to say that everybody hailing from a religious background will have unhealthy ideals regarding perfection. Others who are raised in a more lenient household, where mistakes are readily accepted and pressure is never too heavily applied in academic, athletic or any other areas, may have the view that perfection is something that is impossible to attain and that being flawed is a fundamental part of being human.

It is these varying views on imperfection that have helped largely to shape what society believes to be acceptable in terms of career and academic achievements. Alternate interpretations of and perspectives on imperfection can even shape something as important as our relationships with other people or the way we view ourselves.

Presentation of Myth: Achilles' Heel



Achilles Heel

The Trojan War was one of the most famous events recorded in Greek history. Many stories are written of its heroes and heroines, as well as the gods and goddesses who influenced its outcome. Here is the story of the Greek hero Achilles.

The Trojan War began when Helen, the wife of King Menelaus, of Sparta, was kidnapped by Paris of Troy. Paris carried Helen far across the Aegean Sea and refused to return her to her husband. For ten years legions and armies of Greece attempted to rescue Helen from Troy in Asia Minor.

Achilles was the son of Peleus, a prince, and Thetis, a Nereid, or fairy. It was Thetis's plan to protect her child in a very special way. Since she was immortal, she decided to give her son Achilles some of the supernatural powers that she possessed. Thetis wrapped her baby in a blanket and secretly took him to the underground world of Hades. The river Styx flowed through this dark landscape where the souls of the dead came to rest after their lives on Earth were through.

Thetis held her infant son, Achilles, by his tiny, pink heel and dipped him in the powerful waters of the Styx. Little Achilles let out a terrified cry, for the river was bitter cold. But it possessed a remarkable power. Upon contact, the water would form a protective covering over the baby's skin.

Thetis returned from the underworld with Achilles. Not simply content to offer her son the gift of protective armor, she vowed that she would also make him immortal. Thetis prepared a large fire. She held Achilles over it. When she was about to immerse his tiny body in the flames, her husband, Peleus, came upon her. Thinking that she was trying to harm Achilles, Peleus pushed her away from the fire. Thetis fled with Achilles.

Thetis gave Achilles to the care of Chiron, a wise centaur who had been the tutor of many Greek heroes. Achilles grew into a capable and strong, young man. When the Trojan War broke out, he was eager to go and fight for the honor of Helen. He wished to fight under the command of General Agamemnon.

When Thetis heard of her son's plans, she implored Chiron to convince him not to go to war. But Chiron would not persuade Achilles to forget about fighting. He knew that Achilles had the makings of a great warrior.

In desperation Thetis placed a spell on her son, rendering him powerless. Then she disguised him as a young girl and sent him away to the island of Scyros, where he would be under the protection of King Lycomedes.

Meanwhile, Agamemnon gathered his troops for the siege of Troy. His men were strong and willing to fight. Victory seemed certain. A seer by the name of Calchas, however, predicted that the Greeks would not win the war unless a warrior named Achilles was on their side.

Hearing a rumor that such a man was living on the island of Scyros, Agamemnon dispatched several men to find him. Among them was Odysseus.

Odysseus offered many fine gifts to the daughters of King Lycdomedes. He placed precious jewels and fine cloth before them. All but one daughter was enchanted by Odysseus's gifts. When Odysseus withdrew a spectacular sword from his belt and placed it in front of the young women, he immediately recognized a glint of delight in the eyes of the daughter who was not impressed by his other gifts. The young girl seized the sword.

“Your are Achilles!” Odysseus declared. “You can no longer live here under the protection of your mother, who would have you be a girl. You are destined to be a great fighter on the side of Agamemnon!”

Achilles departed with Odysseus and entered the battlefield of Troy. He fought bravely and ferociously with his fellow Greeks, who greatly admired his skills. Achilles even slew Hector, the son of the Trojan king, Priam.

Weary of all the fighting, and respectful of Achilles's kindness in allowing him to reclaim the body of his dead son, King Priam declared a truce. Unfortunately, Paris was afraid that he would have to return Helen to her husband. He did not want to see the war come to an end. From a tower high atop Priam's place, Paris shot an arrow at Achilles.

The arrow pierced Achilles in the back of his foot. This was the only spot where the magical river Styx had not touched his body because his mother had held him by his heel when she dipped him in its water. Soon after being injured, Achilles died.

The death of the great warrior inspired Agamemnon and Odysseus to continue to fight. After many battles and many deaths, the Greeks succeeded in defeating the Trojans and rescuing Helen. The exploits of Achilles in the Trojan War were recorded in “The Illiad,” the famous poem by Homer, which is still enjoyed by readers to this day.

Myth Rationale



When Thetis, Achilles' mother, dips her son into the river Styx, the protective waters render almost every part of his body immortal; however, as Thetis exposed Achilles' heel whilst dipping the rest of his body into the river, he was never to be fully out of harm's way. Everybody, no matter how outwardly powerful and flawless they appear, has their own personal Achilles heel, something that makes them imperfect and ultimately, human.

There are different types of flaws and while everybody is flawed to a degree, some people are quick to point out others imperfections as being inhuman or unnatural, while conveniently forgetting the flaws that they themselves possess. There are also those who refuse to believe that imperfection exists in any form, and so create impractically high standards for themselves and those surrounding them: they try to sculpt themselves into something that is not realistic and therefore constantly set themselves up for defeat.

Using the myth of Achilles heel as the foundation for my tapestry project, I am going to attempt to compare and contrast two prominent views on imperfection: the first view is that imperfection, in it's finest form, is perfection. The other representation being that flaws in humans are extremely undesirable and that we should all model ourselves after a God who was thoroughly perfect. I will explore the scale of thought on imperfection, from those who believe that perfection is non-existent and all flaws should be accepted, to those that think perfection is something that should be hunted down until it's attained.

First Quote & Quote Reflection



“Better a diamond with a flaw than a pebble without one.”- Confucius

***

Everybody, however desperately they try to hide it, is flawed in different ways: there are physical flaws, such as eyes that are set too far apart, or lips that are too thin, and then there are the flaws that delve deeper than someone's outwardly appearance. There are those who tend to be irresponsible, apathetic or spiteful. Flaws in humans can range far and wide, from unappreciative to envious to intolerant.

Despite the number of imperfect qualities all humans possess, we often seem to overlook the more powerful and admirable qualities we harbor. It is entirely possible for someone to be a forgiving, optimistic and enthusiastic person, while at the same time being self-centered, insincere and indecisive. It is more beneficial to be a person with a large number of positive qualities along with negative ones, than to be someone who is rather indifferent and holds no special personality traits that make them stand out. It is far better to let the world see your weaknesses, to show them that your weaknesses do not define you and that just because you have weaknesses does not make you a weak person.

The word diamond comes from the ancient Greek adámas and means unbreakable: diamonds have a high dispersion of light and they are among the most sought-after gemstones. A pebble is a small rock, one that can be easily found and just as easily forgotten.

This quote ties extensively well into the myth of Achilles; in relation to the quote by Confucius, Achilles would be the flawed diamond. Achilles was a man who was almost perfect, almost immortal. His only major flaw was the spot on his heel which had never felt the healing waters of the Styx river. However, this flaw did not diminish the fact that the rest of his body was imperishable. A pebble without a flaw holds far less value than a diamond that is flawed and so it goes with humans...

Poem & Poem Reflection



The Flaw
Molly Peacock

The best thing about a hand-made pattern
is the flaw.
Sooner or later in a hand-loomed rug,
among the squares and flattened triangles,
a little red nub might soar above a blue field,
or a purple cross might sneak in between
the neat ocher teeth of the border.

The flaw we live by, the wrong color floss,
now wreathes among the uniform strands
and, because it does not match,
makes a red bird fly,
turning blue field into sky.
It is almost, after long silence, a word
spoken aloud, a hand saying through the flaw,
I'm alive, discovered by your eye.

***

Humans, generally speaking, are able to maintain some state of perfection for a limited amount of time; this state of perfection could be in school, if a student is receiving high grades on all the assignments they turn in. The temporary status of perfection could also be fitted to the work space, if the employee is completing all tasks to the best of their ability and being praised highly for doing so. However, this state of perfection can never last long and it is inevitable that eventually we will meet our downfall and do something to showcase our imperfections.

Molly Peacock paints the picture of imperfection as something that can transform an ordinary object, or individual, into something that is enthralling and fresh; that progressive transformation, one which was not originally in your plans, may have come to be based on a mistake you made or a flaw you possess. In the instance of the poem, this means weaving a different picture in your rug than the one you had first planned to weave, but in life, horizons broaden and thus the journey our imperfections can take us on broadens too. Mistakes made and lessons learned from these mistakes can hold colossal value in the work place, school, or even in our relationships with other people.

While some are unable to see beyond their flaws, and the repercussions their flaws will undoubtedly have on them, other people instead choose to view flaws as a window of opportunity in which to better themselves. Just like it is important to take in stride your accomplishments along with your imperfections, it is equally important to accept the idea that your shortcomings can often lead you down a path that can be much more rewarding and stimulating than the one you had originally envisioned yourself embarking upon...

Novel Excerpt & Reflection


Fight Club- Chuck Palahniuk
“I just don't want to die without a few scars, I say. It's nothing anymore to have a beautiful stock body. You see those cars that are completely stock cherry, right out of a dealer's showroom in 1955, I always think, what a waste.”

***

Upon realizing that flaws can spill outside the realm of personality vices or physical blemishes, a discovery is made; imperfections can be mistakes that were made throughout your life time or chances you took that did not always have the ending results you had hoped for. I

n this section of Fight Club, the protagonist, who remains unnamed throughout the entire novel, is reflecting on his recent enrollment with an underground fight club. The quote I chose was part of his internal thinking process after his boss, upon seeing the various bruises and cuts on his face, asked him, “What do you get yourself into every weekend?”

While it is easy to spend your life living in the shadows of those who choose to be audacious and step out of their comfort zone, even if the aftermath of their decisions is less than satisfying, the protagonist of the novel believes that to do so is a waste; you have a body and it is a misuse of this body if you don't make some errors before dying.

It may sound rather obvious, but while many people are willing to acknowledge their imperfections, far fewer people are willing to try and achieve things and make mistakes, in spite of their imperfections. Achilles was one of these brave men; during the war of Trojan, he valiantly fought even when he knew there was a possibility he would die at battle. Achilles was not afraid or ashamed of his imperfections and rather, fought to save his country while simultaneously fighting against his flaws.

While it's fair to say that the protagonist's decision to step bravely into unfamiliar territory is not exactly made in the best context (a dangerous fight club where men are badly beaten routinely), the protagonist does show a clear understanding that boundaries cannot be placed on a person simply because of their imperfections...